Species co-occurrence networks : can they reveal trophic and non-trophic interactions in ecological communities?
Broitman, Bernardo R.
Marquet, Pablo A.
Navarrete, Sergio A.
MetadataShow full item record
KeywordSpecies interactions; Non-trophic interactions; Food webs; Ecological networks; Co-occurrence; Intertidal; Keystone species; Anthropogenic impacts
Co-occurrence methods are increasingly utilized in ecology to infer networks of species interactions where detailed knowledge based on empirical studies is difficult to obtain. Their use is particularly common, but not restricted to, microbial networks constructed from metagenomic analyses. In this study, we test the efficacy of this procedure by comparing an inferred network constructed using spatially intensive co-occurrence data from the rocky intertidal zone in central Chile to a well-resolved, empirically-based, species interaction network from the same region. We evaluated the overlap in the information provided by each network and whether there is a bias for co-occurrence data to better detect known trophic or non-trophic, positive or negative interactions. We found a poor correspondence between the co-occurrence network and the known species interactions with overall sensitivity (probability of true link detection) equal to 0.469, and specificity (true non-interaction) equal to 0.527. The ability to detect interactions varied with interaction type. Positive non-trophic interactions such as commensalism and facilitation were detected at the highest rates. These results demonstrate that co-occurrence networks do not represent well classical ecological networks in which interactions are defined by direct observations or experimental manipulations. Co-occurrence networks provide information about the joint spatial effects of environmental conditions, recruitment, and, to some extent, biotic interactions, and among the latter, they tend to better detect niche-expanding interactions such as positive non-trophic interactions including habitat engineering. Detection of links (sensitivity or specificity) was not higher for well-known intertidal keystone species than for the rest of consumers in the community. Thus, as observed in previous empirical and theoretical studies, patterns of interactions in co-occurrence networks must be interpreted with caution, especially when extending interaction-based ecological theory to interpret network variability and stability. Co-occurrence networks may be particularly valuable for analysis of community dynamics that blends interactions and environment, rather than pairwise interactions alone.
Author Posting. © The Author(s), 2017. This is the author's version of the work. It is posted here under a nonexclusive, irrevocable, paid-up, worldwide license granted to WHOI. It is made available for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Ecology 99 (2018): 690-699, doi:10.1002/ecy.2142.
Suggested CitationPreprint: Freilich, Mara, Wieters, Evie, Broitman, Bernardo R., Marquet, Pablo A., Navarrete, Sergio A., "Species co-occurrence networks : can they reveal trophic and non-trophic interactions in ecological communities?", 2017-12-21, https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.2142, https://hdl.handle.net/1912/10209
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Toward a new data standard for combined marine biological and environmental datasets - expanding OBIS beyond species occurrences De Pooter, Daphnis; Appeltans, Ward; Bailly, Nicolas; Bristol, Sky; Deneudt, Klaas; Eliezer, Menashè; Fujioka, Ei; Giorgetti, Alessandra; Goldstein, Philip; Lewis, Mirtha; Lipizer, Marina; Mackay, Kevin; Marin, Maria; Moncoiffe, Gwenaelle; Nikolopoulou, Stamatina; Provoost, Pieter; Rauch, Shannon; Roubicek, Andres; Torres, Carlos; van de Putte, Anton; Vandepitte, Leen; Vanhoorne, Bart; Vinci, Matteo; Wambiji, Nina; Watts, David; Salas, Eduardo Klein; Hernandez, Francisco (Pensoft, 2017-01-09)The Ocean Biogeographic Information System (OBIS) is the world’s most comprehensive online, open-access database of marine species distributions. OBIS grows with millions of new species observations every year. Contributions ...
Ecological constraints on planktonic nitrogen fixation in saline estuaries. I. Nutrient and trophic controls Marino, Roxanne; Chan, Francis; Howarth, Robert W.; Pace, Michael L.; Likens, Gene E. (Inter-Research, 2006-03-15)Heterocystous, planktonic cyanobacteria capable of fixing atmospheric N2 into available nitrogen (N) are common and critically important to nutrient cycling in many lakes, yet they are rarely observed in estuaries at ...
Suca, Justin J.; Llopiz, Joel K. (2017-09)Deep-water demersal fishes represent an understudied but ecologically important group of organisms. Select species of demersal fishes rely on pelagic prey items, representing a direct transport of surface carbon to greater ...